Sleeping Arrangements by Alice Ashe

“Sleeping Arrangements” by Alice Ashe is the winner of the CRAFT 2025 Dialogue Challenge.
In “Sleeping Arrangements,” the reader is left to eavesdrop on a conversation between two hopeful parents—one who is doing their best to forge ahead while the other attempts to hold onto the dream for one more night. In her author’s note, Alice Ashe writes that her goal in the story was to make the reader feel, and we do. Guided by sentence structure, the reader’s emotions first tumble down and then jerk back and forth—tab once and then back to the margin, one word sentences shift into one word questions: “Keep. Keep? Hon. Honey… What, forever?” While the reader isn’t privy to any backstory, is offered no narrative, no explanation, we know what words pass between the couple as they sort through their hearts and the nursery. We are left to read between the lines, to search through what has been left unsaid, and to mourn alongside them. —CRAFT
Keep.
Keep?
I said keep.
Sure, all right.
These too.
Keep?
Keep.
Okay.
And—keep.
There’s still nothing in the donate pile.
Keep it. Anyway some of this stuff we might use later.
Hon.
We might.
Well. Sure. But someone else probably needs it a lot more than we do.
I just said we might.
Okay, but we can always rebuy—
But that’s wasteful. We already spent so much money.
It’s not wasteful if we give the things to someone who needs them—
I mean it’s a waste of our money. To buy the same things twice.
Right. Okay. But since we don’t need any of this now, we could really use the extra space—
And what if she changes her mind?
Hon.
She already did once.
Well. I don’t think she’s going to again. At this point.
I’m just saying.
Okay. Well what about this, then? Attic?
…
Hon?
…
Honey.
Um. Yeah. Furniture can go in the attic. Just—can you leave the rocker and the crib?
What, forever?
No. God. Just for tonight. You can carry them up tomorrow.
…
Please.
Sure. Of course.
And can you grab me a few blankets from the closet?
Yeah, you cold?
No, I—I want to sleep in here. Tonight.
ALICE ASHE is a writer of poetry and prose whose work has appeared in TriQuarterly, Hawai’i Pacific Review, december, and other journals. She lives in Atlanta with her partner and son.